Talk:Dynamics of Meditation: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
No edit summary |
(Remove superfluous info.) |
||
| (7 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
==== Ch. 8 and 9 one event? ==== | |||
What reasons are for combining ch.8 and 9 as one event [[Dynamics of Meditation ~ 08]]? | |||
--[[User:Sugit|Sugit]] ([[User talk:Sugit|talk]]) | They have the same description, incl. interviewer and date. But in the book these are two separated chapters. Number of words in ch.8 - 7268, in ch.9 - 3973. | ||
:Ch.1: 8138 words. | |||
:Ch.2: 2940 | |||
:Ch.3: 6207 | |||
:Ch.4: 5138 | |||
:Ch.5: 5129 | |||
:Ch.6: 7493 | |||
:Ch.7: 6803 | |||
:Ch.8: 7268 | |||
:Ch.9: 3939 | |||
:Ch.10: 5105 | |||
:Ch.11: 6231 | |||
:Ch.12: 6676 | |||
Above numbers show that second interview was smallest, so it is possible that ch.9 contains text of own interview on the same date as previous interview (ch.8). Other possibility is incorrect description either in ch.8 or in ch.9.--DhyanAntar 08:14, 30 October 2019 (UTC) | |||
---- | |||
I made this assumption that 8 and 9 are one event based on the identical description in the book. I agree with Antar that this is not 100% certain. | |||
But it seems very likely: | |||
#It would be unlikely that there were 2 separate interviews on one date with the same interviewer. | |||
#The first question of ch.9, "prana", can indeed be seen as a continuation of ch.8. | |||
#So until some kind of evidence turns up that there has been an error in the description, I think there is no need to assume two events. | |||
--[[User:Sugit|Sugit]] ([[User talk:Sugit|talk]]) 09:28, 3 November 2019 (UTC) | |||
---- | ---- | ||
Latest revision as of 11:10, 18 February 2022
Ch. 8 and 9 one event?
What reasons are for combining ch.8 and 9 as one event Dynamics of Meditation ~ 08?
They have the same description, incl. interviewer and date. But in the book these are two separated chapters. Number of words in ch.8 - 7268, in ch.9 - 3973.
- Ch.1: 8138 words.
- Ch.2: 2940
- Ch.3: 6207
- Ch.4: 5138
- Ch.5: 5129
- Ch.6: 7493
- Ch.7: 6803
- Ch.8: 7268
- Ch.9: 3939
- Ch.10: 5105
- Ch.11: 6231
- Ch.12: 6676
Above numbers show that second interview was smallest, so it is possible that ch.9 contains text of own interview on the same date as previous interview (ch.8). Other possibility is incorrect description either in ch.8 or in ch.9.--DhyanAntar 08:14, 30 October 2019 (UTC)
I made this assumption that 8 and 9 are one event based on the identical description in the book. I agree with Antar that this is not 100% certain.
But it seems very likely:
- It would be unlikely that there were 2 separate interviews on one date with the same interviewer.
- The first question of ch.9, "prana", can indeed be seen as a continuation of ch.8.
- So until some kind of evidence turns up that there has been an error in the description, I think there is no need to assume two events.
--Sugit (talk) 09:28, 3 November 2019 (UTC)
